Being an investor in precious metals often calls for a need to power up and (or) secure a tremendous asset to beat inflation, be financially stable in an unstable economy, and get a long-term profit. Asides from the usual gold and silver bullion coins, most times, the challenge for regular investors is deciding whether or not to add numismatic coins to their precious metal portfolio.


Although bullion is always a safer investment choice, the truth is that numismatic coins can prove highly beneficial in a long-term investment and yield much more profit. But, the ones most likely to succeed are experienced collectors and savvy investors who know how to make knowledgeable buying & selling decisions.

Could it be that you need advice on bullion and numismatic coins? We’ll enlighten you on everything you need to know about bullion vs. numismatic coins.

Numismatic Coins – How they are different

Numismatics itself is the act of collecting historically significant currencies, including coins, paper money, medals, tokens, and other related things. Numismatic coins are rare and collectible coins with an external value outside and beyond their intrinsic melt value. That’s what distinguishes them from bullion. Bullion of coins or bars always and only draws deals from the amount of their precious metal content (intrinsic value or melt value). A coin’s intrinsic value generates from the amount of precious metal it contains depending on the current spot price.

Numismatic Coins

Depending on the overall timing and the conditions present, numismatic coins can be worth exceedingly higher than the spot price of gold because they have more factors influencing their worth. Investors and collectors need to understand the market of rare coins to spot factors that act as numismatic values.

What is Numismatic Value?

The numismatic value can vary from things associated with the coin, like the age, history, how the coin was minted, and even past significant scenarios related to the coin. But all coins categorized as numismatic items are mainly valued because they are rare and collectible.

Based on the collector’s supply and demand, a coin’s numismatic value is likely to go very high, or sometimes it can vanish completely. However, numismatic coins rarely depreciate in value. They either remain the same or increase. An example of a rare numismatic coin that sold at a tremendously high price and still increased in value is the 1794 “flowing hair” silver dollar coin. This rare silver dollar coin sold for over $7.5 million in 2010 and was later sold in auction for over $10 million in 2013. Even though there are 150 specimens known to exist, the coin is rare to find.

Numismatic Coins Value

Aside from its rarity and historicity, this coin is one of the kinds in the most refined mint state. The Professional Coin Grading Service (PCGS) certified the coin as a Specimen-66, making the coin the finest of its kind.


It was fun highlighting the uniqueness of numismatic coins and how they differ from bullion- now, we have to clear the air. Is one safer than the other? Are there any risks in trying to invest in numismatic coins?

An essential tip for a first-time precious metal buyer is that the decision to invest in bullion or numismatic coins is solely based on your motive as a coin collector.

If you plan to steer towards a stable and sure-return investment, you might want to stay focused on bullion. Bullion coins and bars are popular on the precious metal market as a profitable form of investment; hence, they’re a stable source of income. So, it’s a matter of coin collecting vs. investing in coins.

numismatic coin value over time

On the flip side, numismatic coins are SOLELY just for collectors looking to get their hands on some rare coins partly just for collecting. If you’re that person, when you buy rare coins, you might want to hold them for longer than ten years to secure a reasonable profit. That’s the quirk of antique and rare collectibles like numismatic coins; they become more rare and valuable over time (primarily years).

What is the difference between numismatic and bullion coins?

Bullion and numismatic coins are two distinct categories of coins primarily distinguished by their purpose, value determination, and market. Bullion coins are mainly used for investing, and the metal content and the fluctuating prices of precious metals in the market largely determine their value. They are usually made from gold, silver, platinum, or palladium and are often purchased in large quantities by investors.

On the other hand, numismatic coins are collected more for their historical significance, rarity, condition, and beauty, rather than their metal content. These coins might have been circulated previously as currency and are usually older. Their value can be significantly higher than the precious metal they contain, especially if they are rare or in excellent condition.

What is considered a numismatic coin?

A numismatic coin is any coin with a collectible value significantly above the monetary value of its precious metal. Factors such as the coin’s age, rarity, condition, and historical significance contribute to its numismatic value. Examples of numismatic coins include rare minted coins, ancient coins, discontinued coins, and coins with mint errors.

Can you sell bullion coins?

Yes, you can sell bullion coins. Because bullion coins are minted primarily for investment purposes, their value is tied directly to the current market value of the precious metal they contain. This makes them relatively easy to sell compared to numismatic coins, whose value depends on various factors, including collector demand, condition, and rarity. Most precious metal dealers, coin dealers, and some banks are willing to buy bullion coins.

Are numismatic coins taxable?

Tax laws vary by country, but in the United States, the profit from the sale of numismatic coins can be considered a taxable capital gain. If you sell a numismatic coin for more than what you paid, the difference is regarded as a capital gain and can be subject to tax. However, tax laws are complex and change regularly, so it’s always best to consult a tax advisor or financial planner for the most accurate and up-to-date information.

What type of coins are worth collecting?

The coins worth collecting depend largely on your interests, goals, and budget. Some people enjoy collecting coins from a specific country or period, while others might be interested in coins with unique designs or mint errors. Collecting bullion coins from different mints can also be an exciting way to accumulate precious metals while enjoying various designs.

What is the best coin to start collecting?

If you’re new to coin collecting, start with something exciting and affordable. You might choose to collect coins from the year you were born, coins from different countries, or coins with unique designs. An American Silver Eagle or a Canadian Maple Leaf can be a great starting point for a bullion coin collection due to their popularity, affordability, and silver content.

Investing in Bullion Coins

Investing in bullion coins is a popular way to hold tangible assets. These coins are a great way to invest in precious metals like gold, silver, platinum, and palladium. When buying bullion coins for investment, focus on the most widely recognized and liquid coins, like the American Gold Eagle, Canadian Gold Maple Leaf, or South African Krugerrand.

Bullion and numismatic coins have their place in coin collecting and investing. Bullion coins are best suited for those looking to invest in precious metals and hedge against economic uncertainty, while numismatic coins appeal to those who appreciate the historical significance and artistic beauty of older, rarer coins. Always research and seek advice from coin experts or financial advisors to make informed decisions.

Bottom line

Invest in bullion for short-term profit and invest in numismatic coins for long-term profits. Also, to be sure you are getting a certified rare coin when you buy, get your coin valued by an expert in the field or employ a coin grading service. By the way, if you’re planning to invest in numismatic coins, don’t do so unless you can afford to because the market of rare coins is really unpredictable. Not only is the market scheme of rare coins unpredictable, but due to the uncertainty of the near future, hoarding rare coins can either earn you a huge profit or make you lose some money.

Frequently Asked Questions About Numismatic Coins

Are numismatic coins important?

Numismatic materials are essential in deciphering the economic history of society. They serve to observe the ebb and flow of coinage, the changes in the weight of a coin, and how various precious metals were introduced to circulation.

What are the disadvantages of numismatic coins?

The bad news about numismatics coins is that the coins may have been lightly or heavily damaged through wear and tear. It is possible for some of the excavated.

What are the best rare coins to start with?

 We recommend starting your rare coin collection with low-level investment coins, such as Lincoln Pennies and Washington Quarters. After getting used to the market, you can collect rarer coins, such as Gold American Eagles.

Whether you are new to gold investing or have been a collector for years, it is essential to research and work with a reputable dealer. American Bullion is a trusted resource for those looking to invest in gold IRAs, offering a wide selection of gold coins from around the world and expert guidance on which coins are right for you.

So why wait? Invest in gold coins today and start building a brighter financial future.