The Pros and Cons of a Silver IRA

The average individual has some grand plans to set up a protected chain of assets such as a gold and silver IRA scheme to help ensure their finances while they retire. This often involves indulging in schemes with insurance companies, stacking up stock assets, and hoping they grow into fruition just in time for retirement. You do not have to be limited to doing this with fiat currencies alone but with commodities.

Several firms have explored the opportunity to aid the development of flexible retirement plans in the long term and accumulate gratuity while workers are still in active service.

Silver IRA - pros and cons

Independent Retirement Accounts, abbreviated as IRA, is a cool way to save up for retirement. The IRA system is operated within the provisions of an economy’s internal revenue service. People can save as much money as legally enabled by the IRS.

One of the reasons people are always eager to invest in IRAs is that it offers leverage over tax as little to no deductions are made while the savings plan is active, although this depends on the type of IRA you subscribe to.

Types of IRA

Below are the specific types of IRAs that are available:

    • Basic IRA: You are allowed to pay tax on the contributions made in this project. Upon retirement, deductions on withdrawals from the accumulated earnings will occur.
    • Roth IRA: In this IRA, all contributions are deducted from the post-tax income, and there will be no tax deductions afterward from the earnings and withdrawals.
    • SEP IRA: Small business owners can also save up in the traditional IRA’s retirement plan in the employee’s name.
    • SIMPLE IRA: This is a savings incentive system that operates just like the 401 (k) plan, where employees and employers can contribute to retirement savings. It is a much cheaper alternative to the 401 (k) plan.

Another term you should get familiar with when we are talking about IRAs is called a Rollover. It allows the transfer of assets from one saving plan to another without paying tax on the cash or assets. The money or asset sent to the second retirement savings is referred to as a “rollover contribution.”
IRA types


A rollover is a tax-free distribution of cash or other assets from one retirement plan to another. The distribution to the second retirement plan is called a “rollover contribution.” The IRS website has information on the benefits of rollovers and how, when, and where to do a rollover.

Precious metals IRA

Based on our previous definitions, we often get this a lot. When people hear about retirement savings, all they can imagine is having to save their money in dollars while it appreciates in value.

It is a part of the whole; we are making our money work for our ideology circle. Not a bad idea, but every savings plan is structured to work that way.

precious metals ira

The challenge is to keep a certain amount of dollars for an extended period. The occasional lull in the dollar’s strength that often causes it to depreciate in value is worthy of consideration. Also, cash is heavily taxed, and navigating the market while holding precious metals is a much better idea, given that they tend to appreciate in value.

What is a Silver IRA?

A precious metal IRA is a special retirement savings account not based on dollar investment. Instead, you invest in gold or silver coins and bars.

The rules of a silver IRA are not any different from the already established IRA, except that you can add silver to your portfolio. Regular IRAs mostly contain paper assets such as currencies, bonds, and stocks. IRAs apply to precious metals such as gold, palladium, and platinum.

With silver IRAs, you can easily diversify your portfolio by holding other forms of assets alongside it and offering all-around protection for your investment. It could be the perfect bulletproof for your retirement accounts.

silver ira meaning

Like with traditional IRAs, you can access precious metal IRAs through their own brokerage firms. Silver IRA companies allow you to indulge in paper assets and precious metals, which offer more stability and less cost than the 401 (k) plan.

But how do you manage precious metal IRA? Gold and silver IRA can be accessed through a slightly familiar method known as a self-directed IRA. Ultimately, the IRA categories offer similar tax advantages and operate by the same guidelines but differ in fundamentals. Instead of paper assets instead, you have investments in commodities.

It allows you to explore beyond the type of investment an IRA company offers. The choice of what goes in or out of the IRA account is yours. In terms of precious metals, the challenge is that most companies only gold IRA options leaving out other precious metal options their investors might prefer.

When you opt to buy a silver IRA, you get to buy the commodity at the prevalent silver price.

We recognize the plentitude of IRA options available to you, and these are not limited to gold, platinum, palladium, and cash flow real estate, to mention a few. These are not just virtual assets but real-life hard assets that are visible, and you can touch them.

So any IRA for these commodities is simply an IRA that contains an investment of that precious metal in the retirement account. Let’s say retirement savings account A of Mr. Bart Philips is credited with 100 ounces of silver or another precious metal; the account has thus become a silver IRA account.

A self-directed silver IRA

Now that you understand that a silver IRA is simply an IRA that contains a silver investment in the account, you must know your options when you consider opening a self-directed IRA.

From what we explained about the types of IRA, a self-directed IRA can either be in the form of a traditional or a Roth IRA. The benefits of either type of IRA are applicable depending on your choice.

self directed silver ira


Roth has funded with dollars after-tax deductions, while the traditional IRA is funded with dollars before tax deductions on contributions. However, your investments will grow with silver without having to pay tax on them. But that only works if you keep the gains in the silver IRA.

The IRS is liable to control and limit the number of silver contributions you make annually, and you are bound by the fair contribution limits.

Pros of a self-directed silver IRA

A good hedge against inflation

Silver is the perfect hedge against inflation and other financial chaos. You can stay aloof from all economic volatility that often causes currencies to lose their values over time. The silver price has only known growth for the last decade and has grown tenfold in the last 50 years. The fiat dollar has lost more than 90% of its value in the same period.

Thus, silver offers the greatest protection for your retirement savings as it can withstand the test of time and economic declination. 

Diversified portfolio

Another imperial advantage that silver offers you is a well-diversified portfolio. With paper assets like bonds and stocks, IRAs are often susceptible to dangerous market situations that can depreciate your holdings over an extended period. 

The demand for silver is always on the high end, and it can hold up its valuation for a long time. When choosing a silver IRA, you eliminate the risks of holding paper assets alone. At least, silver can yield growth in your portfolio even when other assets have experienced a dip in value. When the stock market crashes, you will be completely unaffected.

silver demand

When we say a portfolio is diversified, we mean that it contains investments that are not of the same type. So if you invested in company A and Company B that are in the same industry, you don’t have a diversified portfolio as the same market sentiments affect them. But investment in stocks or bonds while holding silver and/or gold in your account is the perfect definition of a diversified asset cache. And they will all perform under their peculiar market conditions.

In your self-directed IRA, you can own physical silver or hold coins made with 99.9% silver. American Bullion accepts the following coins for a silver IRA account:

Lower annual fees

Saving in a silver IRA helps lower fees and deductions incurred when you own the metals directly. You are not paying for insurance or any form of storage costs. 

Cons of silver IRA

Capital gains are the only forms of ROI

Unlike paper assets, holding a silver IRA does not yield dividends or interest on fiat savings. That is a big disadvantage. Over your stock holdings, your IRA receives a percentage of dividends annually and without tax until retirement. This dividend can be reinvested to enjoy some more compound interest. Your money keeps working for you like your interest yields even more interest.

The only interest that will accrue to your silver IRA is what you earn from the rising silver prices. Yet it is not guaranteed that the prices will go higher. To get off money in an IRA, especially Traditional IRA, you will need to sell off your silver probably at the retirement age of 71 years. So, if the price of silver is low at the time of liquidation, you might end up with lesser money than you invested.

silver coins

Silver IRA custody is highly restricted

The best thing that people think about silver investments is that you own a tangible physical asset. That is not entirely true, as the IRS has placed a restriction that stops people from buying silver indiscriminately, stashing them away in a bank’s deposit box, or even showing the coins off at home. It also prevents you from adding silver that you already have into your IRA account. 

Everything you do on your silver IRA must be done through a certified custodian. A typical custodian saves you the stress of buying silver, preparing insurance, and transporting and storing your bullion assets. But it also exposes you to the risk of fraud or theft of your silver. This is possible because you will never get to lay your eyes on your precious metals. You cannot tell if you are buying real silver or even if it is under safe storage.

You must partner with a reputable silver dealer duly approved by the U.S. Commodity Futures Trading Commission.

High costs and Fees

With a custodian, you will be exposed to administrative charges ranging from $250 to $500 per year. The range differs based on the storage facilities’ quality and location. You will also be charged a “spread” rise up to 17-33 percent, depending on how much the company buys and sells the silver. You stand to gain only when the value has risen before reaching the spread amount.

Are gold and silver IRAs a good idea?

Buying and holding physical gold and silver cannot necessarily be called investments because they are not exactly being used. They are a great hedge against inflation– they yield no rents or dividends and do not grow the way a stock will. A precious IRA is thus a much better idea if long-term inflation comes into play.

silver and gold coins

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)

Is a silver IRA a good investment?

Adding silver to your IRA account helps you maintain a diversified portfolio. It can hold its value over time and yield profits with capital gains.

Is there such a thing as a silver IRA?

A silver IRA is a retirement account where you can invest in silver coins and pure physical gold without owning them. 

How to Open a Precious Metal IRA

Register with a reputable self-directed IRA custodian and decide what products to buy, select a depository and complete the transaction